Title: Hide and Seek (Goodreads)
Author: Ian Rankin
Series: Inspector Rebus #2
Published: Wheeler Publishing, 1991
Pages: 397
Genres: Crime
My Copy: Library Book
Buy: Amazon, Book Depository, Kindle (or visit your local Indie bookstore)
Detective Inspector John Rebus is back following the case in Knots and Crosses; this time he finds himself on a case that that may have supernatural elements to it. The body of a drug addict is found in a squat, in between two burnt down candles and a pentagram painted on the wall next to it. While most people were quick to discard this of a heroin overdose, Rebus is determined to investigate to find the true circumstances surrounding this death. What transpires is something far more sinister than a simple overdoes, is it murder? Or even worst, is it a conspiracy?
One thing that I really enjoyed about Knots and Crosses was the way Ian Rankin took on a different approach to the crime genre. The crime took a back seat in the story and the novel spent most of the time developing characters and building the backstory that will set up the rest of the series. I understand that Hide and Seek would not be able to continue developing John Rebus as a character the same way Knots and Crosses but I still expected more. I knew Rankin could write a crime novel that was not formulaic or unoriginal, but Hide and Seek was not on the same level as the first book in the series.
It has been come out that Hide and Seek was Ian Rankin’s attempt in presenting a modern take on The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde. A story that fascinates Rankin; he has even filmed a documentary (Ian Rankin Investigates Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde) exploring the origins of this classic from fellow Scottish writer Robert Louis Stevenson. There are a few nods to the classic found in this book from ‘Hide’ in the title of the novel and the private member’s club known as the Hyde club.
Ian Rankin found himself in the middle of a scandal when a case featuring similarities to the novel became apparent. This scandal was mentioned in parliament and two lawyers opened an investigation into Rankin to determine if there was any connection. While any allegations made towards Ian Rankin turned out to be false, this real life scandal gave this book some extra attention in the public eye.
I was very disappointed with Hide and Seek and will continue my search for a new crime series. I have very particular taste, but mostly I want a series that is dark, gritty, original and does not feel like a ‘crime of the week’ situation; is this too much to ask for? I thought Inspector Rebus may have been a good series to explore, but this novel convinced me otherwise. Not sure if the next book (Tooth and Nail) is any good but I do not think I will be finding out.
I just read this as well. I think I enjoyed it more than you, but it was still a little disappointing. I’m going to carry on for another book before I drop the series, but I definitely get stopping here.
I might be dim, but I don’t really get the Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde connection in this book at all, and I knew he wrote this as a modern take going in.
Do you have any suggestion of good dark crime series, I should check out? I liked Dexter but it was terribly written, but I love the darkness.
I’m fairly new to the genre, so I unfortunately don’t. I love Raymond Chandler’s Marlowe novels, which can deal with the grimey parts of society, but I guess I wouldn’t really call him dark.
I’m in love with Kenneth Branagh’s Wallander television series, which can be quite dark, so I’m planning to read the Henning Mankell novels they’re based on at some point. I have high hopes for those, but can’t give an actual opinion yet.
Sorry to read that this book was disappointing, Michael. I haven’t read any books from the Rebus series but I have read books from Rankin’s Malcolm Fox series, which I thought was interesting because Fox is from the Complaints/police internal affairs and makes his dynamic with other police officers intriguing.